Promptwatch vs LLMagnet 2026
LLMagnet acts in WordPress with llms.txt and Schema. Promptwatch acts with Content Agents, citations, and crawler logs. Sourced loop comparison.
Same vs-query, different place the work happens. LLMagnet writes files inside WordPress and Shopify. Promptwatch runs the visibility program across prompts, citations, crawlers, visitors, and publishing. The two products share the letters GEO and not much else. We rank the loop that still works when the CMS is not WordPress, because that is the loop a brand actually needs.
Loop table
| LLMagnet | Promptwatch | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it acts | WP/Shopify: llms.txt, Schema, robots.txt, IndexNow | SaaS: prompts, citations, logs, CMS publish |
| Write | Discovery files and JSON-LD | Content Agents to Webflow / Framer |
| Fetch evidence | Plugin bot-visit analytics | Agent Analytics from Professional, 25M logs |
| Named answers | Small prompt quota (3 on PLUS, 10 on Enterprise; PRO count unstated) | Explore 10 ChatGPT; Essential 50 prompts, 6,000 responses |
| Entry | Shopify free 500 sessions; WP PRO $29 | Explore free; Essential $95 |
| G2 | Job titles, no names | 4.7/5, 1,840+ customers |
WordPress PRO $29 is not Shopify $29. Keep both sheets, because the two meters do not convert. Yearly WP runs $23, $75, and $112. Shopify yearly runs $278 and $758 on the paid tiers. A finance line that averages the two is wrong by construction.
What LLMagnet automates
Schema next to Yoast or RankMath. WooCommerce AI-to-revenue on Plus and Enterprise. Elementor. Agent-discovery files. Bots on WordPress.org: ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, and Grok, with the plugin updated 15 July 2026. MCP and the Abilities API are opt-in, off by default. The marketing page is dated 26 August 2026. PLUS gives all-bot analytics and 3 prompts. Enterprise gives 10 prompts and chat support. Shopify meters sessions, with 7, 30, and 90 day retention by tier, not prompts. The meter is the thing to read first.
A bot hit is not a recommendation. The plugin can act on the file, and it cannot close a citation gap by publishing a GEO article. That is the line between hygiene and program, and it is the line this table is built on.
What Promptwatch automates
Explore is free. Essential is $95: citation analytics, 200K visitor events, and five AEO articles. Professional is $245: 25M crawler logs, 15 articles, 150 prompts, 18,000 responses, and 1M events. Business is $579. The agency ladder is Kick-off $199, Growth $399, and Scale $799.
Agent Analytics covers ChatGPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, GoogleOther, and the Meta AI crawler, with crawl-to-citation. Visitor analytics runs through a script or GTM. Reddit and YouTube citation views are in the product. ChatGPT Shopping and Ads Radar are in the product. Amsterdam, April 2025, with €2M+ ARR by May 2026. There is no $29 plan, and the LLMagnet $29 tiers are a different product on a different meter.
Price is not the loop
WordPress PLUS $100 versus Essential $95 is a trap. Three prompts versus fifty, plus 6,000 responses and visitor events. The sticker is close and the loop is not. Shopify $79, with 100,000 sessions, versus Professional $245, with 25M crawler logs and 15 articles, is sessions versus program. Kick-off $199 versus Enterprise $149 is unlimited projects versus 10 prompts. Each of those comparisons looks like a price fight and is actually a unit fight, and the unit decides.
Who we send where
LLMagnet is for the WordPress team that needs files and Schema in place this week, and the Shopify store that wants auto llms.txt on the free session cap. Both are real jobs, and the plugin does them.
Promptwatch is for anyone whose next step is named answers or publish. Content Agents when the CMS is Webflow or Framer. Agent Analytics when the brief includes crawlers. Visitor analytics when the brief includes conversions. The next step is the thing to name, because the next step is what picks the product.
Run the plugin for WP hygiene. Run Promptwatch for the program. Do not let a visibility score become the QBR number, because a score is an output and a QBR needs a ticket. Shopify free, with 500 sessions and 7-day retention, and Explore, with 10 ChatGPT prompts, are both $0 and still not interchangeable. WordPress PRO lists ChatGPT and Claude analytics, and the .org listing names Perplexity, Gemini, and Grok bots too. Read the SKU, then the plugin card, in that order.
Profound is an Enterprise-agent buy, not the winner of this table. Otterly.AI and Peec AI stay last. That order holds across the directory, and it holds here.
FAQ
Does LLMagnet replace Content Agents?
No. Files versus articles. The plugin writes discovery files, and Content Agents publish GEO articles to a CMS.
Off by default: MCP. Is that a missing feature?
It is an opt-in. Off is the documented default, and we read that as a choice, not a gap.
Which log is agentic?
Promptwatch Agent Analytics. Plugin bot hits are fetches on that CMS, not crawl-to-citation across properties.